What Price Would Your Buy-Sell Agreement Set if It Were Triggered Today?
What Price Would Your Buy-Sell Agreement Set if It Were Triggered Today?
November 17, 2026
The Agreement Sets the Price. Owners Should Know That Price Before a Triggering Event.
A buy-sell agreement is a contract that says who may or must buy an owner’s interest in a business when that owner dies, retires, or leaves, and how the price is set. The price set in the agreement may be far from what the business is actually worth, and the parties involved may interpret the terms differently. Every owner with a buy-sell agreement should know what price the agreement would set if it were triggered today.
A valuation prepared under the agreement’s own terms shows the parties what to expect. The best time for that valuation is while every owner is living and no one knows who will be the buyer and who will be the seller. If the price surprises anyone, the owners can still change the agreement.
Two Ways a Buy-Sell Agreement Can Surprise the Parties
The first surprise is often how high or low the price of an owner’s interest is once the agreement is triggered. A price term written years ago may produce a figure far from the fair market value of the business on that day. One party may receive much less than expected, or the other may owe far more than planned.
The second surprise is that the parties may read the same price term differently and disagree on the calculation. The disagreement may not surface until an owner has died or left and can no longer explain the term.
In one Iowa case a brother and his sister were in disagreement as to their mother’s estate. The sister was the executor, and the disagreement arose over the formula in the family company’s buy-sell agreement. The agreement called the result of the formula “fair market value.” Their calculations were roughly $20,000 per share apart, and the dispute lasted about three years and went to trial.¹
In another Iowa case an agreement set the price of a deceased owner’s shares at book value. The executor of the owner’s estate argued that book value meant fair market value. The trial court noted that no party disputed “a gross disconnect” between the company’s book value and its economic value.²
How a court would treat a particular agreement depends on its terms, the facts, and the governing law. The price is a separate question, and the owners can have it calculated today under the agreement as written.
How the Price in a Buy-Sell Agreement Works
Agreement terms can vary, but generally the price is set as a fixed amount, at book value, by a formula, or through an appraisal process. Those terms carry specific meanings that may differ from what the parties assume. Book value is an accounting figure. It is the excess of a company’s assets over its liabilities as shown on its books. An appraisal usually determines fair market value, which is the price at which an interest would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, with neither forced to act and both reasonably informed of the relevant facts.
Other provisions of the agreement also affect the outcome, including the date as of which the price is measured, the person who makes the calculation, and whether the purchase is an option or an obligation.
Key concept: the price comes from the terms of the agreement, not from the market. A term such as book value, a formula, or a fixed amount can produce a price far from the fair market value of the business. The time to learn that price is while every owner can still act.
Where Valuation Comes In
A valuation prepared under the terms of the agreement shows the price that would be paid for an owner’s interest if a triggering event occurred today. The appraiser applies the agreement’s price provisions to the company’s current financial information.
Where the agreement calls for an appraisal, the answer also depends on the standard of value it names and on whether discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability apply. Those discounts reflect that a minority interest cannot direct the company and has no ready market.
The owners should compare the price under the agreement with the fair market value of the same interest. A wide difference is not necessarily a defect, because the parties may have reasons to choose a price that favors the company or the remaining owners. What matters is that the parties understand the difference while they can still decide whether to keep the term.
A Hypothetical Example
Assume Alan Brandt and Denise Marlow each own half of Northbrook Industrial Supply. Their buy-sell agreement, signed when the company was much smaller, requires the company to buy a deceased owner’s shares at book value. Neither owner has read the price term in years. They request two separate analyses as of today: the price under the agreement and the fair market value of the company. In very simple terms:
| 100% Equity | 50% Equity | |
|---|---|---|
| Price under the agreementBook value. Assets less liabilities as shown on the company’s balance sheet. | $3.0 million | $1.5 million |
| Appraised valueFair market value. The half is a pro rata share, before any discounts. | $9.0 million | $4.5 million |
| Difference for one owner’s half$4.5 million less $1.5 million. | $3.0 million |
If Denise died today, the company would buy her shares for $1.5 million under the agreement, and Alan would be the only shareholder. Suppose Denise had always understood book value to be another way of saying fair market value. She would have expected her estate to receive $4.5 million, and the offer would be $1.5 million. Alan would be following the agreement as he reads the term. If he died first, the result would run the other way, and neither owner knows which one will be the seller.
Alan and Denise now know both outcomes. They can decide whether to change the buy-sell agreement or accept the difference. Valuing the interest under the terms of the agreement and under a fair market value standard removes much of the uncertainty surrounding a triggering event. It is a recommended best practice to run this exercise while the owners are alive and the parties are amicable.
What the valuation does for Alan and Denise: the valuation turns the terms of the agreement into dollars as of today. The price is known in advance of a triggering event, and the company and the parties can plan accordingly.
Signs Your Agreement May Be Worth a Closer Look
- You do not know whether your company has a buy-sell agreement.
- You have a buy-sell agreement and do not know what price it would set for your interest today.
- The price term uses book value, a formula, or a fixed amount, and no one has compared the result with the fair market value of the business.
- The business has grown or changed since the agreement was signed.
- You have not reviewed your buy-sell agreement in the last five years.
At Eubank Capital, we provide independent, defensible valuations of closely held business interests for buy-sell planning. We work with the owners and their attorney to calculate the price under an existing agreement as of a current date, and we appraise the same interest at fair market value so the two figures can be compared. When an agreement is triggered and calls for an appraisal, we serve as the independent appraiser.
Request a Buy-Sell Valuation Review
¹ Lee v. Meloan, No. 09-1328 (Iowa Ct. App. June 30, 2010).
² In re Estate of Frink, No. 05-1674 (Iowa Ct. App. Oct. 25, 2006).
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or valuation advice. Any buy-sell agreement, its price term, the valuation of an interest under the agreement, and related estate and tax analysis should be reviewed and implemented by qualified legal, tax, and accounting advisors based on the reader’s specific facts and circumstances. The court disputes mentioned are described in general terms and are not a statement of Iowa law. The values in the hypothetical example are illustrative only. The individuals and the company in the hypothetical example are fictitious, and any resemblance to real persons or businesses is purely coincidental.